Based on The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne
Amy Scurria, Composer
Carol Gilligan, Librettist
Jonathan Gilligan, Librettist
Creator’s Note
This work draws on Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter but seeks to tell a different story—not Hawthorne's, but one that uses Hawthorne's characters and circumstances, and is informed by a 21st-century feminist worldview.
This feminist vision is not alien to Hawthorne. Although his novel is said to be the third most widely assigned novel in high schools, few people remember how radically feminist (for the mid-19th century) Hawthorne's language and ideas are. Hawthorne's tour de force lies in making an adulteress sympathetic. In contrast to the pious patriarchs who judge her, he portrays her not merely as a pitiable repentant sinner, but one whose strength and clarity of vision is recognized by members of the community—so strong was Hester Prynne, with a woman's strength.
The novel closes with Hester's prophecy that "at some brighter period, when the world should have grown ripe for it, in Heaven's own time, a new truth would be revealed." However, in keeping with his time, Hawthorne ultimately emphasizes her self-abnegation, denying her the realization of this new relation between the sexes.
Hawthorne's vision of a revolution in relations based on mutual happiness, and his observation of the role of a puritanical patriarchy in opposing this vision, inspired us to tell a similar story—one in which we can see the truth Hawthorne denies her. In our historical research on 17th-century Puritan New England, we discovered it was far more liberated and free for women than later myths suggest, featuring greater equality before the law and basic literacy education for girls. Yet, as women like Anne Hutchinson began putting this theological egalitarianism into practice, the authorities felt threatened and declared male primacy essential to order.
Pearl explores these profound historical and human tensions, bringing to light the voice and vision Hawthorne could only imagine.
The Synopsis
Pearl revolves around an array of intense personal and political frictions: Hester Prynne and the minister, Dimmesdale, love each other and yearn to be together; their daughter Pearl longs to know her father and live in a nuclear family. Yet coming together would cost Dimmesdale his ambitions as the charismatic leader of the community congregation—and with it, the power he wields to protect Hester and Pearl from the other patriarchs. More deeply, the rigid marriage laws of the era would destroy the equipoise of his relationship with Hester, making him her master rather than her equal.
The opera is anchored by Pearl herself—seven years old as the events unfold, but also appearing as an adult remembering her childhood and trying to make sense of it. She struggles to understand why she could see everything so clearly yet was pressed by her mother to keep her observations secret, and why no one else seemed able to see what was so obvious to her. She wonders why her mother, after escaping a community she found oppressive, chose to return once Pearl was grown, and where God was while all of this transpired.
Ultimately, the opera focuses on the changing perceptions of Pearl, Hester, and Dimmesdale. The core tensions—between private passion and public duty, between the roles of lover, parent, and citizen, and between moral codes and personal truth—are as fraught and urgent today as they were in the mid-seventeenth century.
Pearl Workshop Excerpts
Shakespeare & Company
Lenox, MA
PRODUCTION DETAILS
Duration:
2 Acts - 1 hour, 45 minutes (2 hours total with intermission)
Status: Available for world premiere stage productions
ORCHESTRAL FLEXIBILITY
PIANO / VOCAL
FLEXIBLE: custom instrumentation options available upon request
PRINCIPAL VOCAL ROLES
Soprano or Lyric Mezzo-Soprano
Child Soprano
Soprano
Tenor
Baritone
Bass
SATB Chorus
ADULT PEARL
CHILD PEARL
HESTER PRYNNE
ARTHUR DIMMESDALE
ROGER CHILLINGWORTH
REVEREND WILSON
CHORUS
Critical Acclaim
"Scurria has a remarkable melodic sense; Moments of remarkable tenderness are expressed between Dimmesdale and Prynne. The duet 'If God is love, can love be sin' was gripping and memorable, as was the limpid moment when he sings 'Hester, take down your hair.' Scurria's lyrical writing and tenor John Bellemer's sensitive singing as Dimmesdale brought out the wonderful musicality of the name 'Hester Prynne'—so lovingly phrased, evoking such tenderness in the name, that I wondered if this is a classic love song in the making, like Bernstein's 'Maria'."
— Liane Curtis, Boston Musical Intelligencer (Review of the workshop performance)
PERFORMANCES & WORKSHOPS
Shakespeare & Company (Lenox, MA | August 5, 2013)
Piano/vocal concert performance produced by Sara Jobin and the Different Voice Opera Project.
American Cultural Center at the University of Shanghai (Shanghai, China | March 15–25, 2013)
Excerpts presented.
Greensboro Cultural Center Recital Hall (Greensboro, NC | March 8, 2013)
Lecture-recital featuring operatic discussion and live excerpt performances with soprano and composer at the piano.
Shakespeare & Company (Lenox, MA | August 13, 2012)
Piano/vocal concert performance produced by Sara Jobin and the Different Voice Opera Project.
UNC Chapel Hill (Chapel Hill, NC | September 17, 2011)
Excerpts presented.
Informal Workshop (Carol Gilligan’s Residence)
Casual developmental reading and preview with feedback.
Academic Origin
Developed and composed as the doctoral dissertation in music composition, Duke University.
ACADEMIC MILESTONES & GRANTS
Grants & Support
Evan Frankel Fellowship, Duke University (2012–2013)
Aleane Webb Dissertation Research Award, Duke University (2012)
Summer Research Fellowship, Duke University (2011)
Conference Presentations
Presenter / Featured Screening, Feminist Theory and Music Conference (Hamilton College)
Academic Milestone
Ph.D. Dissertation in Music Composition — Duke University